Civista Bancshares Stock Price and Value Analysis

Civista Bancshares (NasdaqCM:CIVB) in our automated value investing analysis, with the cash flow history and price comparison below.

Key Facts

Advertisement helps keep Trendshare free for most readers.

Hold-time calculator

Estimate how long you need to hold Civista Bancshares to reach your target.

Target type

CIVB Free Cash Flow Trend

Free Cash Flow trendline for CIVB
Free Cash Flow trendline for Civista Bancshares
CSV

Based on historical returns, we believe that Civista Bancshares can grow its free cash at a rate of about 1%. That's positive!

AdvantagesDisadvantages
  • This stock looks overpriced.
  • This company is less known than others.
  • This company is making money at a modest rate.

Inside the CIVB Numbers

CIVB Price
(Civista Bancshares stock price per share)
$28.07
[?] CIVB Fair Price
(based on intrinsic value)
$26.24
[?] CIVB Safety Price (based on a variable margin of safety) $15.74
Try your own return

The fair price above uses a 10.1% discount rate, the long-run US stock return (10.1% geometric, 1926 to 2025, from Bessembinder's working paper, updated 2026-11-09), and 2.5% terminal growth. A higher rate suits a higher return target and gives a lower value.

Value per share:

[?] PE Ratio versus Sector 23% lower than other Financial Services stocks
[?] PE Ratio versus Industry 0% lower than other Banks - Regional stocks
[?] Free Cash Flow Jitter 32%
[?] Dividend Yield 2.48% (tax impact)
Shares Shorted 613,350

Insider Activity Summary

In the six months to 2026-11-19, 1 insider bought in 2 trades, about $11 thousand, and no insider sold shares.

The six months before that had no buys or sales.

Recent Insider Activity

Open-market buys and sells reported by Civista Bancshares's officers, directors, and 10% owners on SEC Form 4. Routine transactions (tax withholding, option exercises, and stock grants) are excluded -- these are discretionary trades only.

Date Insider Type Shares Price
2026-09-23 Parcher Charles A. (President) Buy 315 $26.75
2026-09-23 Parcher Charles A. (President) Buy 85 $26.75
2025-11-18 Weaks Nathan E Buy 1,000 $21.49
2025-08-21 Weaks Nathan E Buy 500 $19.85
2025-08-18 Weaks Nathan E Buy 500 $19.95
2025-08-05 Whinnem Ian (SVP/CFO) Buy 1,500 $19.20
2025-07-31 Weaks Nathan E Buy 1,000 $19.35
2025-07-30 Weaks Nathan E Buy 206 $19.90
2025-07-30 Weaks Nathan E Buy 1,794 $19.88
2025-07-11 DUTTON RICHARD J (Senior Vice President) Buy 4,000 $21.25

This stock has short interest! This means that people have shorted it.

Why does that matter? They've made a bet that price will decrease from where they bought it. Maybe there are financial problems, or maybe there's a value play.

As of the latest analysis, there are 613,350 shares shorted. With 20,198,769 shares available for purchase and an average trading volume over the past 10 trading days of 134,910, it would take at least 4.5 days for all of the short holders to cover their shorts.

Related guides: good annual rate of return · high-yield stocks · forecasting earnings growth

Free Cash Flow by Fiscal Year

How to read this: free cash flow in plain terms, free cash flow jitter.

Each year names the SEC filer that reported it, so a change of filer shows up here.

Fiscal yearSEC filer (CIK)Free cash flow (USD millions)
2010 944745 20.3
2011 944745 19.6
2012 944745 15.8
2013 944745 11.7
2014 944745 13.9
2015 944745 13.9
2016 944745 16.3
2017 944745 19.4
2018 944745 18.1
2019 944745 36.8
2020 944745 30.6
2021 944745 38.8
2022 944745 22.2
2023 944745 59.3
2024 944745 44.6
2025 944745 39.8

Download the yearly data as CSV.

Cash Conversion

How to read this: what free cash flow is, why earnings matter.

Over the 15 fiscal years from 2010 to 2025 with positive net income, operating cash flow totaled $430.3 million against net income of $352.1 million, or 1.22 times. Net income was negative in 1 of the 16 years, and those years are left out of the ratio.

In 2025, operating cash flow was 0.94 times net income, compared with 3.96 times for the earliest three years (2010 to 2012).

In 2025, capital expenditures were $1.2 million, 2.7% of operating cash flow of $43.3 million, which leaves an estimated $42.1 million after capex. Across the 16 years with reported capex, it averaged 7.6% of operating cash flow. This uses that year's own capital expenditures, not the five-year average behind the free cash flow table, so the two can differ.

Cash conversion in 2025 was 0.94, at least 0.25 under the 3.96 earliest three-year ratio. Gaps like this come from non-cash gains or from cash tied up in receivables, inventory or other working capital.

Fiscal yearNet income (USD millions)Operating cash flow (USD millions)Capital expenditures (USD millions)Operating cash flow / net income
2010 -1.3 21.5 1.2 n/a
2011 4.0 20.8 1.2 5.27
2012 5.6 16.9 0.9 3.03
2013 6.2 12.8 1.2 2.07
2014 9.5 14.9 0.5 1.56
2015 12.7 15.1 2.0 1.18
2016 17.2 17.7 2.4 1.03
2017 15.9 20.8 1.0 1.31
2018 14.1 19.6 1.5 1.39
2019 33.9 38.8 3.2 1.15
2020 32.2 32.7 2.0 1.01
2021 40.5 40.8 1.9 1.01
2022 39.4 25.2 6.5 0.64
2023 43.0 62.7 3.4 1.46
2024 31.7 48.2 4.2 1.52
2025 46.2 43.3 1.2 0.94

Where the Cash Went

How to read this: why companies buy back shares, dividend yield explained.

Over the 10 fiscal years from 2016 to 2025 with dividend or share repurchase facts, estimated free cash flow totaled $326.0 million. That estimate uses the average of up to five years of capital expenditures, not each year's own, so it is not a reported figure.

In the 10 of those years with dividend payment facts, dividends paid totaled $74.0 million, 22.7% of the estimated free cash flow of those years. Estimated free cash flow was at least the dividends paid in 10 of those 10 years.

In 4 of the 10 years, cash spent repurchasing shares was at least 5% of that year's estimated free cash flow, and in those years it totaled $56.6 million. Smaller amounts are left out of this sentence because they can be shares withheld to pay employees' taxes on stock awards.

In 2025, dividends paid were $11.8 million, 29.7% of estimated free cash flow of $39.8 million.

Fiscal yearEstimated free cash flow (USD millions)Dividends paid (USD millions)Cash spent repurchasing shares (USD millions)Total returned (USD millions)Total as a percent of estimated free cash flow
2016 16.3 3.3 n/a 3.3 19.9%
2017 19.4 3.7 0.0 3.7 19.0%
2018 18.1 4.7 n/a 4.7 26.2%
2019 36.8 7.2 3.9 11.1 30.2%
2020 30.6 7.1 13.5 20.6 67.2%
2021 38.8 8.0 22.3 30.3 78.1%
2022 22.2 8.5 16.9 25.4 114.5%
2023 59.3 9.6 1.6 11.2 18.9%
2024 44.6 10.1 0.2 10.2 22.9%
2025 39.8 11.8 0.2 12.0 30.2%

Free cash flow here is an estimate: operating cash flow less the average of up to five years of capital expenditures. Cash spent repurchasing shares can include shares withheld to pay employees' taxes on stock awards. The entry n/a means the filings gave no usable figure, not that the amount was zero. Source: the company's annual reports to the SEC.

Revenue and Cash Margin

How to read this: earnings and margins.

Revenue was $13.3 million in 2016 and $19.0 million in 2025, a compound annual growth rate of 4.1% over 9 years.

Revenue fell 0.5% from 2024 to 2025.

Our estimated free cash flow was $39.8 million in 2025, 209.4% of revenue. In 2016 the estimated margin was 122.6%. This estimate charges each year with the average of up to five years of capital expenditures, so it is not the free cash flow the company reported.

Fiscal yearRevenue (USD millions)Estimated free cash flow (USD millions)Estimated free cash flow / revenue
2016 13.3 16.3 122.6%
2017 13.6 19.4 142.3%
2018 15.3 18.1 118.5%
2019 17.8 36.8 206.8%
2020 16.9 30.6 180.8%
2021 19.6 38.8 197.8%
2022 24.5 22.2 90.3%
2023 30.4 59.3 194.7%
2024 19.1 44.6 233.4%
2025 19.0 39.8 209.4%

Balance Sheet

How to read this: how debt and assets are compared, the current ratio.

In 2025, cash and equivalents were $77.3 million against total liabilities of $3793.0 million, or 2.0% of total liabilities. Total liabilities include everything the company owes, not only borrowed money.

Total liabilities were 87.5% of total assets in 2025, compared with 91.2% in 2010, a decrease of 3.7 percentage points.

Stockholders equity was $543.5 million in 2025, compared with $97.0 million in 2010, a rise of 460.6%.

Based on our estimated free cash flow, cash flow return on invested capital (CROIC) was 0.9% in 2025. Invested capital here is total assets less cash and current liabilities.

Fiscal yearTotal assets (USD millions)Cash and equivalents (USD millions)Total liabilities (USD millions)Stockholders equity (USD millions)
2010 1100.6 n/a 1003.7 97.0
2011 1113.0 n/a 1010.4 102.5
2012 1137.0 n/a 1033.0 104.0
2013 1167.5 n/a 1039.2 128.4
2014 1213.2 n/a 1097.3 115.9
2015 1315.0 n/a 1189.9 125.2
2016 1377.3 n/a 1239.6 137.6
2017 1525.9 40.5 1341.4 184.5
2018 2139.0 41.8 1840.1 298.9
2019 2309.6 46.6 1979.4 330.1
2020 2768.9 137.0 2418.8 350.1
2021 3012.9 264.2 2657.7 355.2
2022 3639.4 43.4 3310.7 328.8
2023 3861.4 60.4 3489.4 372.0
2024 4098.5 63.2 3710.0 388.5
2025 4336.5 77.3 3793.0 543.5

Price Versus Our Estimated Value

Free cash flow was positive in all 16 fiscal years we have for Civista Bancshares under its current SEC filer.

Our fair value estimate for Civista Bancshares is $26.24, below its current price of $28.07.

Civista Bancshares's average free cash flow rose sharply, from $18.6 million in its earliest three years to $47.9 million in its latest three.

Year-to-year variability in free cash flow is uneven, measured at 32%.

Civista Bancshares pays a dividend yield of 2.48%.

Our value investing guide explains how to test these numbers against the filings themselves.

Compared With Its Sector and Industry

How to read this: the price to earnings ratio.

Its trailing P/E ratio is 23% below the average for stocks in the Financial Services sector.

Its trailing P/E ratio is in line with the average for stocks in the Banks - Regional industry.

A P/E ratio depends on trailing earnings, which one-time items can distort, so a lower P/E is not by itself evidence of value.

SEC Filer History

Every fiscal year on this page is reported by one SEC filer, CIK 944745.

Each figure on this page comes from that filer.

Risks to This Analysis

How to read this: understanding investment risk.

  • These figures are automated calculations from SEC filings and the recent price. They may contain errors, and they do not reflect lawsuits, management changes, or other events the filings do not show.

How This Page Is Made

Latest annual report used
Fiscal year 2025
Price and market data last refreshed
2026-11-18
Model assumptions last reviewed
2026-11-09

Company figures come from the annual reports (Form 10-K) that each company files with the SEC, read from the SEC EDGAR company facts data. The share price and other market data come from a market data provider.

Free cash flow here is operating cash flow minus capital spending. To keep one unusual year from swinging the result, each year is charged with the average of up to five years of capital spending, so the figure is an estimate and not the free cash flow a company reports.

The fair price is the present value of ten years of projected free cash flow plus a terminal value, discounted at 10.1 percent a year, the long-run return of US stocks, with 2.5 percent growth after year ten. The figures on this page are estimates, not advice.

This analysis covers US companies that file 10-K annual reports. Free cash flow describes banks, real estate investment trusts and funds poorly, so treat their figures with extra caution. In the cash returned and balance sheet tables, a value of zero is treated as a gap in the data, not as a real zero.

Read the filings yourself: CIVB annual reports (10-K) on SEC EDGAR. To try your own growth rate, use the intrinsic value calculator on this page. Our editorial standards explain how Trendshare handles its sources and corrections.

Advertisement supports free stock analysis content.

Questions to Answer Before You Invest in CIVB

Does Civista Bancshares have a coherent story? Does it have a plan to continue to make money? Is it worth your time? Only you can decide where to go from here. Our investment guide helps you ask the right questions, including how to buy stocks. Use these research links for more information.

Worked example: CIVB

This example shows how we apply the Trendshare checklist to CIVB: earnings power, cash generation, valuation, and margin of safety.

We check: business quality, free cash flow, P/E, and margin of safety.

  1. Step 1 — Snapshot

    • Price: 28.07
    • Market cap: $581M
    • EPS: 2.78
  2. Step 2 — Valuation checks

    • P/E: 10.097
    • FCF yield: —
    • Date checked: Nov 18, 2026
  3. Step 3 — Margin of safety

    • Compare price to fair value and safety price.
    • Look for durable cash generation and reasonable leverage.
    • Decide if it passes your personal checklist.