Selective Insurance Group Stock Price and Value Analysis

Selective Insurance Group (NasdaqGS:SIGI) with its current price, filing history and research links below. Our cash flow valuation does not fit this type of company, so there is no fair price.

Key Facts

Advertisement helps keep Trendshare free for most readers.

Inside the SIGI Numbers

SIGI Price
(Selective Insurance Group stock price per share)
$103.25
[?] PE Ratio versus Sector 6% lower than other Financial Services stocks
[?] PE Ratio versus Industry 39% lower than other Insurance - Property & Casualty stocks
[?] Dividend Yield 1.67% (tax impact)
Shares Shorted 1,921,537

Insider Activity Summary

No open-market insider buys or sells are recorded for the last 12 months.

This stock has short interest! This means that people have shorted it.

Why does that matter? They've made a bet that price will decrease from where they bought it. Maybe there are financial problems, or maybe there's a value play.

As of the latest analysis, there are 1,921,537 shares shorted. With 55,321,354 shares available for purchase and an average trading volume over the past 10 trading days of 423,340, it would take at least 4.5 days for all of the short holders to cover their shorts.

Why This Page Shows No Fair Price

Trendshare's cash flow valuation is built for operating companies, which sell goods or services and keep what is left after paying for the equipment they need. It does not fit banks, insurers, real estate investment trusts (REITs) or funds. Their cash flows include deposits, loan repayments, insurance premiums and distributions the company must pay out, so free cash flow does not measure what the business earns for its owners. For that reason this page shows no fair price, safety price or price comparison for Selective Insurance Group. The price and basic facts above come from market data, and the filing history below comes from the company's own SEC reports.

To judge a company like this, read its filings on SEC EDGAR. Our investment guide explains the measures that suit each kind of company.

Compared With Its Sector and Industry

How to read this: the price to earnings ratio.

Its trailing P/E ratio is 6% below the average for stocks in the Financial Services sector.

Its trailing P/E ratio is 39% below the average for stocks in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry.

A P/E ratio depends on trailing earnings, which one-time items can distort, so a lower P/E is not by itself evidence of value.

Closest Industry Peers

These are companies in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, the ones closest in market capitalization to Selective Insurance Group, limited to companies whose pages we publish. The figures come from our latest data for each company.

CompanyMarket cap (USD millions)P/EDividend yield
Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) 6,091 12.4 1.7%
RLI Corp. (RLI) 6,563 16.7 1.0%
White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. (WTM) 5,238 5.9 0.0%
Mercury General Corporation (MCY) 4,510 7.0 1.5%
The Hanover Insurance Group (THG) 8,352 11.7 1.6%
Kinsale Capital Group (KNSL) 8,972 17.4 0.2%
HCI Group (HCI) 2,344 7.6 0.8%

Industry labels are approximate, and companies in one industry can run quite different businesses, so a peer may not be a close match.

Ratios on different fiscal calendars are not strictly comparable, and a trailing P/E can be distorted by one-time items.

Revenue and Cash Margin

How to read this: earnings and margins.

Revenue was $1,590 million in 2008 and $5,337 million in 2025, a compound annual growth rate of 7.4% over 17 years.

Revenue rose 9.8% from 2024 to 2025.

Our estimated free cash flow was $1,205 million in 2025, 22.6% of revenue. In 2008 the estimated margin was 14.7%. This estimate charges each year with the average of up to five years of capital expenditures, so it is not the free cash flow the company reported.

Fiscal yearRevenue (USD millions)Estimated free cash flow (USD millions)Estimated free cash flow / revenue
2008 1,590 233 14.7%
2009 1,514 219 14.5%
2010 1,565 152 9.7%
2011 1,597 117 7.3%
2012 1,734 222 12.8%
2013 1,904 333 17.5%
2014 2,035 231 11.4%
2015 2,132 382 17.9%
2016 2,284 330 14.4%
2017 2,470 380 15.4%
2018 2,586 452 17.5%
2019 2,846 468 16.4%
2020 2,922 540 18.5%
2021 3,379 753 22.3%
2022 3,558 779 21.9%
2023 4,232 734 17.3%
2024 4,862 1,075 22.1%
2025 5,337 1,205 22.6%

Balance Sheet

How to read this: how debt and assets are compared, the current ratio.

In 2025, cash and equivalents were $18 million against total liabilities of $11,547 million, or 0.2% of total liabilities. Total liabilities include everything the company owes, not only borrowed money.

Total liabilities were 76.2% of total assets in 2025, compared with 80.4% in 2009, a decrease of 4.2 percentage points.

Stockholders equity was $3,609 million in 2025, compared with $1,002 million in 2009, a rise of 260.0%.

Based on our estimated free cash flow, cash flow return on invested capital (CROIC) was 8.0% in 2025. Invested capital here is total assets less cash and current liabilities.

Fiscal yearTotal assets (USD millions)Cash and equivalents (USD millions)Total liabilities (USD millions)Stockholders equity (USD millions)
2009 5,115 n/a 4,112 1,002
2010 5,232 n/a 4,214 1,018
2011 5,685 n/a 4,627 1,058
2012 6,794 n/a 5,704 1,091
2013 6,270 n/a 5,116 1,154
2014 6,575 n/a 5,299 1,276
2015 6,904 12.8 5,506 1,398
2016 7,356 37.4 5,824 1,531
2017 7,686 44.7 5,973 1,713
2018 7,953 16.9 6,161 1,792
2019 8,797 8 6,602 2,195
2020 9,688 15.2 6,949 2,739
2021 10,461 45.1 7,479 2,983
2022 10,802 25.2 8,275 2,528
2023 11,803 13.3 8,848 2,954
2024 13,514 63 10,394 3,120
2025 15,156 18 11,547 3,609

SEC Filer History

Every fiscal year on this page is reported by one SEC filer, CIK 230557.

Each figure on this page comes from that filer.

Risks to This Analysis

How to read this: understanding investment risk.

  • These figures are automated calculations from SEC filings and the recent price. They may contain errors, and they do not reflect lawsuits, management changes, or other events the filings do not show.

How This Page Is Made

Latest annual report used
Fiscal year 2025
Price and market data last refreshed
2026-11-20

Company figures come from the annual reports (Form 10-K) that each company files with the SEC, read from the SEC EDGAR company facts data. The share price and other market data come from a market data provider.

This analysis covers US companies that file 10-K annual reports. No fair price is shown for this company, because free cash flow does not describe banks, insurers, real estate investment trusts and funds. In the balance sheet and revenue tables, a value of zero is treated as a gap in the data, not as a real zero.

Read the filings yourself: SIGI annual reports (10-K) on SEC EDGAR. Our editorial standards explain how Trendshare handles its sources and corrections.

Questions to Answer Before You Invest in SIGI

Does Selective Insurance Group have a coherent story? Does it have a plan to continue to make money? Is it worth your time? Only you can decide where to go from here. Our investment guide helps you ask the right questions, including how to buy stocks. Use these research links for more information.