Civista Bancshares Stock Price and Value Analysis

Should you buy Civista Bancshares stock? (NasdaqCM:CIVB). Let's see how it does in our automated value investing analysis system.

CIVB Free Cash Flow Trend

Free Cash Flow trendline for Civista Bancshares

Based on historical returns, we believe that Civista Bancshares can grow its free cash at a rate of about 1%. That's positive!

AdvantagesDisadvantages
  • This stock looks overpriced.
  • This company is making money at a modest rate.
  • This company is less known than others.

Inside the CIVB Numbers

CIVB Price
(Civista Bancshares stock price per share)
$28.07
[?]
CIVB Fair Price
(based on intrinsic value)
$26.24
[?]
CIVB Safety Price (based on a variable margin of safety) $15.74
Try your own return

The fair price above uses a 10.1% discount rate, the long-run US stock return (10.1% geometric, 1926 to 2025, from Bessembinder's working paper, updated 2026-11-09), and 2.5% terminal growth. A higher rate suits a higher return target and gives a lower value.

Value per share:

[?]
PE Ratio versus Sector 23% lower than other Financial Services stocks
[?]
PE Ratio versus Industry 0% lower than other Banks - Regional stocks
[?]
Free Cash Flow Jitter 32%
[?]
Dividend Yield 2.48% (tax impact)
Shares Shorted 613,350

Insider Activity Summary

In the six months to 2026-11-19, 1 insider bought in 2 trades, about $11 thousand, and no insider sold shares.

The six months before that had no buys or sales.

Recent Insider Activity

Open-market buys and sells reported by Civista Bancshares's officers, directors, and 10% owners on SEC Form 4. Routine transactions (tax withholding, option exercises, and stock grants) are excluded -- these are discretionary trades only.

Date Insider Type Shares Price
2026-09-23 Parcher Charles A. (President) Buy 315 $26.75
2026-09-23 Parcher Charles A. (President) Buy 85 $26.75
2025-11-18 Weaks Nathan E Buy 1,000 $21.49
2025-08-21 Weaks Nathan E Buy 500 $19.85
2025-08-18 Weaks Nathan E Buy 500 $19.95
2025-08-05 Whinnem Ian (SVP/CFO) Buy 1,500 $19.20
2025-07-31 Weaks Nathan E Buy 1,000 $19.35
2025-07-30 Weaks Nathan E Buy 206 $19.90
2025-07-30 Weaks Nathan E Buy 1,794 $19.88
2025-07-11 DUTTON RICHARD J (Senior Vice President) Buy 4,000 $21.25

This stock has short interest! This means that people have shorted it.

Why does that matter? They've made a bet that price will decrease from where they bought it. Maybe there are financial problems, or maybe there's a value play.

As of the latest analysis, there are 613,350 shares shorted. With 20,198,769 shares available for purchase and an average trading volume over the past 10 trading days of 134,910, it would take at least 4.5 days for all of the short holders to cover their shorts.

Is Civista Bancshares Stock on Sale?

We believe that Civista Bancshares may be worth examining further. It's making money, which is a very positive sign. Is it on sale?

Civista Bancshares looks overpriced right now. If you're looking for a bargain in the stock market, you should probably look elsewhere for a great deal. This might still be a great stock to own—but it's not on sale right now.

Should You Buy CIVB Stock?

Does Civista Bancshares have a coherent story? Does it have a plan to continue to make money? Is it worth your time? Only you can decide where to go from here. Our investment guide helps you ask the right questions, including how to buy stocks. Use these research links for more information.